US judge allows ‘Killing Jews’ ad on NYC buses: free speech or defamation?
City officials say that the message displayed by the American Freedom Defense Initiative ad is hateful and divisive, but First Amendment lawyers say it cannot be legally banned.
On Tuesday, a federal judge in Manhattan ordered that the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) display a controversial ad from a pro-Israel group on buses. The MTA declined to run the ad last year, saying that its message could incite violence and terrorism. Now, United States District Court Judge John Koeltl ruled that the ad qualified as protected speech, and granted a preliminary injunction ordering that the transportation authority run it.
The advertisement is paid for by the self-proclaimed human rights group, the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI), and was meant to parody a campaign by the Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR) called “My Jihad.” CAIR’s website states that the My Jihad campaign aims to “take back Islam from Muslim and anti-Muslim extremists alike.” The AFDI ad, meanwhile, shows a menacing looking man wearing a scarf around his head and face. A quote to the man’s right attributed to “Hamas MTV” says, “Killing Jews is worship that draws us close to Allah.” Below the quote the ad reads: “That’s His Jihad. What’s yours?”
MTA officials said that the ad could be misinterpreted as a call to violence against Jews, and thus could be banned by an exception to the First Amendment that restricts speech inciting imminent violence.
Viewpoints expressed herein are of the article’s author(s), or of the person(s) or organization(s) quoted or linked therein, and do not necessarily represent those of The Olive Branch Report
Subscribe to my daily newsletter, and join hundreds of daily readers and receive news and relevant commentary
Don't forget to follow The Olive Branch Report on Facebook and Twitter. Now available on your Amazon Kindle Device. Please help spread the word about us, share our articles on your favorite social networks.
If you value what you see on The Olive, please consider donating, any amount helps. We derive NO revenue from this site, and upkeep is expensive.
I seek first the kingdom of Christ because everything else in this world is perishing. All that I have is from God who is always faithful. I have worked hard all my life and will continue as long as God lends me breath. The mistakes and bad judgments I made in my life all stemmed from me trying to work things out by myself. I have learned the hard way that the victory over all of my problems and the answers to all of my desires lie solely in my Savior, Jesus Christ.
It is now my desire to share the words that God gives me to encourage and give hope to others who need the strength that only faith in Christ can give.